Former Manchester United manager Ole Gunnar Solskjaer has voiced his surprise over the club’s decision to sell homegrown midfielder Scott McTominay to Napoli, a move that continues to spark debate among supporters. United allowed the Scottish international to leave in August 2024 for £25.7 million, ending a journey that began when he joined the academy at eight years old. He went on to make 258 first-team appearances, becoming one of the most trusted squad players during Solskjaer’s tenure. The transfer, however, has taken on new significance as McTominay thrives in Italy while United struggles with midfield depth.
McTominay’s Rise in Serie A
The decision to let McTominay go appeared questionable at the time, and his performance since joining Napoli has added fuel to the debate. He has already scored 14 league goals since his arrival, contributing heavily to Napoli’s 2024–25 Serie A title triumph. This season, he has added two more goals, helping the club maintain its position at the top of the league. His dynamic energy, ability to score crucial goals and strong physical presence have made him a fan favourite in Naples. Napoli’s midfield balance has improved with his versatility, and his impact has surprised even analysts who expected a slower adjustment period.
Solskjaer’s Reaction to the Transfer
Solskjaer, who oversaw much of McTominay’s development, admitted he was “shocked” when he learned United had sanctioned the sale. He praised McTominay as a hardworking professional, loyal academy graduate and dependable performer who always delivered when needed. During his time as manager, Solskjaer relied on McTominay in big matches, valuing his aggression, tactical intelligence and leadership qualities. His reaction reflects a broader sentiment among former players and fans who believe United undervalued the midfielder’s role in maintaining midfield stability.
Manchester United’s Midfield Struggles
United’s current situation makes the transfer even more controversial. The club sits in mid-table and faces a lack of depth in central midfield. Injuries, inconsistent performances and tactical changes have left the squad unbalanced. With the departure of McTominay, United lost a physically strong box-to-box midfielder who could score, defend and carry the ball forward. This absence has amplified calls for the club to re-sign him, especially as the January transfer market approaches. Supporters argue that letting a proven academy player leave while facing structural midfield issues reflects deeper mismanagement.
Growing Interest in a Potential Return
Although McTominay has settled well in Italy, reports indicate that Manchester United have shown interest in bringing him back. Fans remain divided on the possibility. Some want his leadership and physicality back at Old Trafford, while others believe the club should focus on long-term rebuilds rather than revisiting old decisions. McTominay’s value has risen since his successful spell at Napoli, making any potential negotiations more complex. Napoli may be unwilling to sell, especially with the player contributing significantly to their title defence.
A Transfer That Continues to Raise Questions
The sale of McTominay has become a symbol of broader frustrations among supporters regarding transfer decisions and squad planning. His success in Italy highlights what United lost, while the team’s current struggles underline the need for a more strategic approach. Solskjaer’s comments add weight to the growing conversation, especially coming from a manager who trusted McTominay during key moments of his tenure. The story also reflects the unpredictable nature of transfers, where a move that seems logical at one moment can appear misguided as circumstances change.
The Ongoing Legacy of a Homegrown Talent
Regardless of where his career takes him next, McTominay’s journey stands as a testament to United’s academy culture. He grew through the ranks, earned his place in the senior squad and became a reliable figure in midfield. His success at Napoli shows his growth, adaptability and resilience. For United fans, his story blends pride in his development with regret over his departure. As the season progresses, his impact abroad and Solskjaer’s surprise will likely keep the discussion alive, raising questions about the club’s long-term vision.
